Название: Finance & Grow Your New Business
Автор: Angie Mohr
Издательство: Ingram
Жанр: Малый бизнес
Серия: 101 for Small Business Series
isbn: 9781770408784
isbn:
• The customers you are “buying” may have only been loyal to the former owner and may choose not to stay on as customers when you take over.
Financial Considerations in the Build-versus-Buy Decision
Once you have taken into consideration your personal goals and your tolerance of risk, the decision to buy versus build a business comes down to a financial one. There are many ways to analyze a purchase decision, but we will look at the most common: the discounted cash flow method.
Discounted cash flow analysis (DCF) helps us to look at a purchase decision and figure out at what point our cash inflows (revenue) match and then exceed our cash outflows (operating and financing costs). DCF takes into consideration the important fact that the timing of the inflows and outflows of cash are different. A dollar received three years from now is worth less than a dollar that we have to spend today. This is called the time value of money and is the basis of DCF analysis. For more information on cash flows, please refer to Financial Management 101, the second book in the Numbers 101 for Small Business series.
Let’s look at an example to see DCF in action:
You have been offered the opportunity to purchase a sign-making company for $225,000. You have already talked to your bank manager and she is willing to finance $175,000 but you will have to use $50,000 of your own savings to finance the rest. You have been thinking about starting up a similar type of company for some time and you want to compare the cash flows of purchasing an existing business versus building one from scratch.
Considering a start-up business
You have put together a cash flow projection for the proposed start-up company. The five-year cash flow projection is shown in Sample 1.
Sample 1: Cash Flow Projection for a Start-Up Business
In this start-up company, you would be investing $50,000 of your own money in order to finance the start-up costs of $18,860 and the cash shortfalls in years one and two ($17,060 and $7,250 respectively). By year three, the company is projected to have a cash surplus, which grows annually up to year five.
You can see that before you even open the doors, you will have to invest $18,860 into the company. Most of that money goes towards buying the sign-making equipment and inventory. Further investments in equipment will have to be made every year as the company starts increasing sales.
How can we evaluate whether or not this option would be a sound investment? There are many methods of decision analysis. The method we’ll consider here is to look at discounted cash flows. This method allows us to come up with an annualized return on investment. Remember that you will invest $50,000 into this venture. You could have taken that $50,000 and put it in the stock market or invested it in bonds. Both of those activities would have generated a return. In the same manner, we can look at the return from this start-up business.
The annualized return on investment is simply the amount of funds left over to put in the owners’ pocket after all of the business expenses are paid. Note that we are talking about all the expenses, which includes remuneration for all work done in the business. In this scenario, you will be paid a management salary of $48,000 in years one and two, $59,000 in years three and four, and $63,000 in year five.
If, however, your cash flow projections don’t allow for you to be paid for your labor, calculating a return on investment is rather meaningless. It means that, not only are you investing money, you are investing your labor for free (this is known as “sweat equity”). In this scenario, however, you are being paid for your efforts and therefore can look at how much you’re getting for your $50,000 investment.
The net cash available for distribution to the owners looks like this:
On start up | ($18,860) |
Year 1 | ( 17,060) |
Year 2 | ( 7,250) |
Year 3 | 9,650 |
(YEA!! Positive cash flow!) | |
Year 4 | 25,590 |
Year 5 | 46,390 |
We also know from the above discussion that a dollar received or spent tomorrow is worth less than a dollar received or spent today. This means that we will want to discount this stream of cash flows back to today, to the present value of the dollar, to make sure we are comparing apples to apples, so to speak. The first thing that we need to do is to find a meaningful interest rate at which to discount the cash flows. After speaking with your banker, you know that you can borrow from the bank at 10 percent, so we will use this rate to do our discounting.
Let’s follow through the example, using a portion of the present value table reproduced below:
Period | 10% |
1 | 0.9091 |
2 | 0.8264 |
3 | 0.7513 |
4 | 0.6830 |
5 | 0.6209 |
This table tells us, for example, that if we are going to receive a dollar a year from now, it is only really worth 90.91¢ today. You can see that, as we go farther into the future, the worth of that same dollar becomes less and less. We have to bring all of our cash flows back to a common point: today. Sample 2 has completed the calculations.
Sample 2: Discounted Cash Flows for a Start-Up Business
This tells us that, over five years, the company will generate $13,171 in net positive discounted cash flow. We also know that you СКАЧАТЬ