Форс-мажор не приговор. Правила ведения дел в эпоху стабильной нестабильности. Сергей Елин
Чтение книги онлайн.

Читать онлайн книгу Форс-мажор не приговор. Правила ведения дел в эпоху стабильной нестабильности - Сергей Елин страница 4

СКАЧАТЬ округа от 17.06.2019 по делу № А76-26950/2018.

      5

      Постановление Арбитражного суда Восточно-Сибирского округа от 03.10.2018 по делу № А58-660/2018.

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 СКАЧАТЬ