The Philosopher's Toolkit. Julian Baggini

Чтение книги онлайн.

СКАЧАТЬ is true regardless of the truth or falsehood of its components can be considered to be empty; its content does no work.

      This is not to say that tautologies are without philosophical value. Understanding tautologies helps one to understand the nature and function of reason and language.

      Valid arguments as tautologies

      As it turns out, all valid arguments can be restated as tautologies – that is, hypothetical statements in which the antecedent is the conjunction of the premises and the consequent the conclusion. In other words, every valid argument may be articulated as a statement of this form: ‘If w, x, and y are true, then c is true’, where w, x, and y are the argument’s premises and c is its conclusion. When any valid argument is substituted into this form, a tautology results.

      Law of non‐contradiction

      In addition, the law of non‐contradiction – a cornerstone of philosophical logic – is also a tautology. The law may be formulated this way:

      Not (p and not‐p).

      The law is a tautology since, whether p is true or false, the complete statement will turn out to be true.

      The law of non‐contradiction can hardly be said to be uninformative, since it’s the foundation upon which nearly all logic is built. But, in fact, it’s not the law itself that’s informative so much as any attempt to break it.

      Attempts to break the law of non‐contradiction themselves require contradictions, and it’s standardly accepted that contradictions are obviously, and in all circumstances, false. A contradiction flouts the law of non‐contradiction, since it asserts both that something is true and that something is false in precisely the same sense and at the same time – asserting, as it were, both p and not‐p. Given, however, that the law of non‐contradiction is a tautology, and thus in all circumstances true, there can be nothing more clearly flawed and senseless than asserting a contradiction in opposition to it – unless, that is, you’re a dialetheist in logic (see 3.10).

      The principle of non‐contradiction has also been historically important in philosophy. The principle underwrote ancient analyses of change and plurality and is crucial to Parmenides of Elea’s sixth‐century BCE proclamation that ‘what‐is is and cannot not‐be’. It also seems central to considerations of identity – for example, in Leibniz’s claim that objects that are identical must have all the same properties.

      Self‐refuting criticism

      One curious and useful feature of the law of non‐contradiction is that, as Aristotle shows in his Metaphysics Book 4, any attempt to refute it presupposes it, and so for Aristotle nothing can be more certain than the principle of non‐contradiction. (See also Plato’s formulation at Republic IV, 436b–437a.)

      To argue that the law of non‐contradiction is false is to imply that it is not also true. In other words, the critic presupposes that what he or she is criticising can be either true or false but not both true and false. But this presupposition is just the law of non‐contradiction itself – the same law the critic aims to refute! In other words, anyone who denies the principle of non‐contradiction simultaneously affirms it. It is, in short, a principle that cannot be rationally criticised, because it’s presupposed by all rationality.

To understand why a tautology is necessarily, and in a sense at least, uninformatively true, and why a self‐contradiction is necessarily false, is to understand the most basic principle of logic. The law of non‐contradiction is where those two concepts meet and so is perhaps best described as the keystone, rather than cornerstone, of philosophical logic.

      SEE ALSO

      1 1.4 Validity and soundness

      2 1.6 Consistency

      3 3.10 Contradiction/contrariety

      4 5.6 Leibniz’s law of identity

      5 7.5 Paradoxes

      READING

       Aristotle (384–322 BCE). Interpretation, esp. Chs 6–9

       Aristotle (384–322 BCE). Posterior Analytics, Bk 1, Ch. 11:10

       Graham Priest, J.C. Beall, and Bradley Armour‐Garb (eds) (2004). The Law of Non‐contradiction (2004)

      Конец ознакомительного фрагмента.

      Текст предоставлен ООО «ЛитРес».

      Прочитайте эту книгу целиком, купив полную легальную версию на ЛитРес.

      Безопасно оплатить книгу можно банковской картой Visa, MasterCard, Maestro, со счета мобильного телефона, с платежного терминала, в салоне МТС или Связной, через PayPal, WebMoney, Яндекс.Деньги, QIWI Кошелек, бонусными картами или другим удобным Вам способом.

/9j/4AAQSkZJRgABAQEBLAEsAAD/7SJGUGhvdG9zaG9wIDMuMAA4QklNBAQAAAAAAAccAgAAAgAA ADhCSU0EJQAAAAAAEOjxXPMvwRihontnrcVk1bo4QklNBDoAAAAAAOUAAAAQAAAAAQAAAAAAC3By aW50T3V0cHV0AAAABQAAAABQc3RTYm9vbAEAAAAASW50ZWVudW0AAAAASW50ZQAAAABDbHJtAAAA D3ByaW50U2l4dGVlbkJpdGJvb2wAAAAAC3ByaW50ZXJOYW1lVEVYVAAAAAEAAAAAAA9wcmludFBy b29mU2V0dXBPYmpjAAAADABQAHIAbwBvAGYAIABTAGUAdAB1AHAAAAAAAApwcm9vZlNldHVwAAAA AQAAAABCbHRuZW51bQAAAAxidWlsdGluUHJvb2YAAAAJcHJvb2ZDTVlLADhCSU0EOwAAAAACLQAA ABAAAAABAAAAAAAScHJpbnRPdXRwdXRPcHRpb25zAAAAFwAAAABDcHRuYm9vbAAAAAAAQ2xicmJv b2wAAAAAAFJnc01ib29sAAAAAABDcm5DYm9vbAAAAAAAQ250Q2Jvb2wAAAAAAExibHNib29sAAAA AABOZ3R2Ym9vbAAAAAAARW1sRGJvb2wAAAAAAEludHJib29sAAAAAABCY2tnT2JqYwAAAAEAAAAA AABSR0JDAAAAAwAAAABSZCAgZG91YkBv4AAAAAAAAAAAAEdybiBkb3ViQG/gAAAAAAAAAAAAQmwg IGRvdWJAb+AAAAAAAAAAAABCcmRUVW50RiNSbHQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAABCbGQgVW50RiNSbHQAAAAA AAAAAAAAAABSc2x0VW50RiNQeGxAcsAAAAAAAAAAAAp2ZWN0b3JEYXRhYm9vbAEAAAAAUGdQc2Vu dW0AAAAAUGdQcwAAAABQZ1BDAAAAAExlZnRVbnRGI1JsdAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAFRvcCBVbnRGI1Js dAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAFNjbCBVbnRGI1ByY0BZAAAAAAAAAAAAEGNyb3BXaGVuUHJpbnRpbmdib29s AAAAAA5jcm9wUmVjdEJvdHRvbWxvbmcAAAAAAAAADGNyb3BSZWN0TGVmdGxvbmcAAAAAAAAADWNy b3BSZWN0UmlnaHRsb25nAAAAAAAAAAtjcm9wUmVjdFRvcGxvbmcAAAAAADhCSU0D7QAAAAAAEAEs AAAAAQABASwAAAABAAE4QklNBCYAAAAAAA4AAAAAAAAAAAAAP4AAADhCSU0EDQAAAAAABAAAAB44 QklNBBkAAAAAAAQAAAAeOEJJTQPzAAAAAAAJAAAAAAAAAAABADhCSU0nEAAAAAAACgABAAAAAAAA AAE4QklNA/UAAAAAAEgAL2ZmAAEAbGZmAAYAAAAAAAEAL2ZmAAEAoZmaAAYAAAAAAAEAMgAAAAEA WgAAAAYAAAAAAAEANQAAAAEALQAAAAYAAAAAAAE4QklNA/gAAAAAAHAAAP////////////////// //////////8D6AAAAAD/////////////////////////////A+gAAAAA//////////////////// /////////wPoAAAAAP////////////////////////////8D6AAAOEJJTQQIAAAAAAAQAAAAAQAA AkAAAAJAAAAAADhCSU0EHgAAAAAABAAAAAA4QklNBBoAAAAAA08AAAAGAAAAAAAAAAAAAAqRAAAH AwAAAA0AOQA3ADgAMQAxADEAOQAxADAAMwAyADEAOQAAAAEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQAA AAAAAAAAAAAHAwAACpEAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAQAAAAAQAA AAAAAG51bGwAAAACAAAABmJvdW5kc09iamMAAAABAAAAAAAAUmN0MQAAAAQAAAAAVG9wIGxvbmcA AAAAAAAAAExlZnRsb25nAAAAAAAAAABCdG9tbG9uZwAACpEAAAAAUmdodGxvbmcAAAcDAA СКАЧАТЬ